Ok here's the situation. Forum with SQL server background, we are having a problem with one forum under one category where all the replies are going to a single topic.
The topic says 4 replies, you click it and there are none, or sometimes it has the latest one. There is one topic that ALL of the replies to the other topics are going to. The forum has been deleted and re-created, the category has been deleted and re-created. Topic count has been performed each time, and yet after a few posts to the forum all of the replies end up under one topic.