You're welcome. 
I haven't added it to show on amongst the topic review or replies, as the mod only replaced the original post icon in topic.asp and forum.asp (and post.asp don't have the post icon in the original code).
The following should accomplish what you want. The line numbers given might not correspond to your post.asp, just so you know. I have marked the code you should add in red.
In post.asp, look for the following (about line 1380-1383):
'## Forum_SQL
strSql = "SELECT M.M_NAME, T.T_DATE, T.T_MESSAGE, T.T_MSGICON "
strSql = strSql & " FROM " & strMemberTablePrefix & "MEMBERS M, " & strActivePrefix & "TOPICS T "
strSql = strSql & " WHERE M.MEMBER_ID = T.T_AUTHOR AND T.TOPIC_ID = " & strRqTopicID
Then look for the following on lines 1397-1398:
Response.Write "><font color=""" & strForumFontColor & """ face=""" & strDefaultFontFace & """ size=""" & strDefaultFontSize & """><small>" & getCurrentIcon(getCurrentMsgIcon(rs("T_MSGICON")),"","hspace=""3""") & "Posted - " & ChkDate(rs("T_DATE"), " :" ,true) & "</small><hr size=""" & strFooterFontSize & """><span class=""spnMessageText"">" & formatStr(rs("T_MESSAGE")) & "</span></font></td>" & vbNewline
Response.Write " </tr>" & vbNewline
Then look for this on lines 1400-1406:
rs.close
set rs = nothing
'## Forum_SQL - Get all replies to Topic from the DB
strSql ="SELECT M.M_NAME, R.R_DATE, R.R_MESSAGE, R.R_MSGICON "
strSql = strSql & " FROM " & strMemberTablePrefix & "MEMBERS M, " & strActivePrefix & "REPLY R "
strSql = strSql & " WHERE M.MEMBER_ID = R.R_AUTHOR AND R.TOPIC_ID = " & strRqTopicID
' DEM --> Added check for moderation so that only admins and moderators can see the unapproved posts.
Then the following on lines 1435-1443:
mM_NAME = 0
rR_DATE = 1
rR_MESSAGE = 2
rR_MSGICON = 3
for iReply = 0 to recReplyCount
ReplyMemberName = allReplyData(mM_NAME, iReply)
ReplyDate = allReplyData(rR_DATE, iReply)
ReplyMessage = allReplyData(rR_MESSAGE, iReply)
ReplyMsgIcon = allReplyData(rR_MSGICON, iReply)
And the last change, look for lines 1462-1464:
Response.Write "><font color=""" & strForumFontColor & """ face=""" & strDefaultFontFace & """ size=""" & strDefaultFontSize & """><small>" & getCurrentIcon(getCurrentMsgIcon(ReplyMsgIcon),"","hspace=""3""") & "Posted - " & ChkDate(ReplyDate, " :" ,true) & "</small><hr size=""" & strFooterFontSize & """><span class=""spnMessageText"">" & formatStr(ReplyMessage) & "</span></font></td>" & vbNewline & _
" </tr>" & vbNewline
strI = strI + 1