Line 69 isn't just:
strSql = strSql & "RESULT, VICTOR) VALUES (" & _
Doesn't it apply to all this as well?
strSql = strSql & "RESULT, VICTOR) VALUES (" & _
"'" & request.form("TYPE") & "'," & _
"'" & request.form("CHALLENGER") & "'," & _
"'" & thisChallenger("ladder_spot") & "'," & _
"'" & request.form("DEFENDER") & "'," & _
"'" & thisDefender("ladder_spot") & "'," & _
"'" & request.form("SCENARIO") & "'," & _
"'" & thisEQUIP("EQUIP") & "',"
Because they are joined up using & _ so get treated as one line... I'm not sure what the problem is, but it may help you debug...