Quoters v/s Spammers - Postet den (1955 Views)
Junior Member
spyderuk
Innlegg: 211
211
Who's the worst?
Realising I have a few compulsive quoters on my forum I started searching around here and found many topics about code changes to do various things about the quotes although many topics seemed to be abandoned. I searched for this in the past and I'm sure I stumbled on a topic that had a quick code change to check for member level and only show the icon/link to "reply with quote" to admins and moderators. I cannot seem to find that topic now.sad
If any of you experienced coders could post that snippit of code here I sure would appreciate it. blush
Thanks.
EDIT.. Or maybe point out the lines and I could comment them out for a board wide quoting bann for a while. that would work for me bigsmile If it would work that way.<
Snitz 3.4.05. Mods Installed, Additional Smilies, Poll's, PM's, Email All Users, Today/Yesterday, Active Users 4, Portal Mod, My Own Google, Referer Mod, Avatars, Intergrated Conqueror Chat, Usergroups, IPGate, File Attachment Mod & Image Resize Mod. Next Mod? My Snitz Forum wink
   
 Sidestørrelse 
Postet den
Senior Member
MarkJH
Innlegg: 1722
1722
Originally posted by spyderuk
Who's the worst?
Realising I have a few compulsive quoters on my forum I started searching around here and found many topics about code changes to do various things about the quotes although many topics seemed to be abandoned. I searched for this in the past and I'm sure I stumbled on a topic that had a quick code change to check for member level and only show the icon/link to "reply with quote" to admins and moderators. I cannot seem to find that topic now.sad
If any of you experienced coders could post that snippit of code here I sure would appreciate it. blush
Thanks.
EDIT.. Or maybe point out the lines and I could comment them out for a board wide quoting bann for a while. that would work for me bigsmile If it would work that way.
LOL

Sorry, couldn't resist. That is one of the most annoying things that people do on a forum, that's for sure.<
Bandlink.net - http://www.bandlink.net/
Bandlink Music Forums - http://www.bandlink.net/forum/
Postet den
Senior Member
MarkJH
Innlegg: 1722
1722
Sounds like it just needs an mlev check around the reply with quote code.
Not tested but how about changing the code in topic.asp from (and it might be a little different in my heavily modded forum):

Code:
if ((Cat_Status <> 0 and Forum_Status <> 0 and Topic_Status = 1) or (AdminAllowed = 1 and Topic_Status <= 1)) and ArchiveView = "" then
Response.Write " <a href=""post.asp?" & ArchiveLink & "method=ReplyQuote&REPLY_ID=" & Reply_ReplyID & "&TOPIC_ID=" & Topic_ID & "&FORUM_ID=" & Forum_ID & """>" & getCurrentIcon(strIconReplyTopic,"Reply with Quote","align=""absmiddle"" hspace=""0""") & "</a>" & vbNewLine
end if

to

Code:
if ((Cat_Status <> 0 and Forum_Status <> 0 and Topic_Status = 1) or (AdminAllowed = 1 and Topic_Status <= 1)) and ArchiveView = "" and mlev > 2 then
Response.Write " <a href=""post.asp?" & ArchiveLink & "method=ReplyQuote&REPLY_ID=" & Reply_ReplyID & "&TOPIC_ID=" & Topic_ID & "&FORUM_ID=" & Forum_ID & """>" & getCurrentIcon(strIconReplyTopic,"Reply with Quote","align=""absmiddle"" hspace=""0""") & "</a>" & vbNewLine
end if

I think this occurs in two places.<
Bandlink.net - http://www.bandlink.net/
Bandlink Music Forums - http://www.bandlink.net/forum/
Postet den
Senior Member
leatherlips
Innlegg: 1838
1838
Postet den
Junior Member
spyderuk
Innlegg: 211
211
Originally posted by leatherlips
I turned off the quote feature in my forums except for MODs and Admin. See here.
Cheers Leatherlips, that was the topic I had seen in the past. Could not find it for looking last night. Going to fire up Cute now bigsmile<
Snitz 3.4.05. Mods Installed, Additional Smilies, Poll's, PM's, Email All Users, Today/Yesterday, Active Users 4, Portal Mod, My Own Google, Referer Mod, Avatars, Intergrated Conqueror Chat, Usergroups, IPGate, File Attachment Mod & Image Resize Mod. Next Mod? My Snitz Forum wink
Postet den
Forum Moderator
dayve
Innlegg: 5820
5820
I rely heavily on quoting, it makes it easy to identify specific things that people say, especially if you're commenting on something someone said pages earlier. I'm not sure eactly what constitutes quote abuse??<
Postet den
Support Moderator
pdrg
Innlegg: 2897
2897
Personally I find quoting can be very habdy in an unthreaded forum like Snitz, it means you can identify the parts of the topic you are referring to, and can be handy for aggregation. However, if the problem is quotes containing quotes containing quotes, I agree reading it can get ugly. In this case I'd suggest either a quick readability class for your users ('never quote more than one level deep, you idiots')...
Or you could parse out the inner quote when a new one is posted. I'm sure one of our regex bunnies could work out a tech solution to that in something less than two minutes (although stitching it reliably into the code will be longer, maybe)...
Or, the 'reply with quote' functionality could automatically dump any previous quotes when pressed, so only leaving the edit pane with the actual body text the previous message.
Not bad, three solutions in three minutes ;-)<
Postet den
Forum Moderator
dayve
Innlegg: 5820
5820
I never liked the way quotes were handled in Snitz, I prefer the entire quote to be in a bordered object which is what I do on my forum and much easier on the eyes, especially with nested quotes.<
Postet den
Senior Member
MarkJH
Innlegg: 1722
1722
I've been using this Quote MOD for a while now. Looks far better than the standard quote code.<
Bandlink.net - http://www.bandlink.net/
Bandlink Music Forums - http://www.bandlink.net/forum/
Postet den
Junior Member
spyderuk
Innlegg: 211
211
Originally posted by pdrg
However, if the problem is quotes containing quotes containing quotes, I agree reading it can get ugly.
That is when you can read the whole topic in the last postsmile
EDIT.. MarkJH I just took a look at that quote mod. Looks quite nice and only a few minor code changes. I may have to try that out. Thanks.<
Snitz 3.4.05. Mods Installed, Additional Smilies, Poll's, PM's, Email All Users, Today/Yesterday, Active Users 4, Portal Mod, My Own Google, Referer Mod, Avatars, Intergrated Conqueror Chat, Usergroups, IPGate, File Attachment Mod & Image Resize Mod. Next Mod? My Snitz Forum wink
 
Du må legge inn en melding