Quick opinion question - Posted (1652 Views)
Senior Member
muzishun
Posts: 1079
1079
I am working on a MOD to make a forum a "Suggestion Box", and I am looking for advice. I have some of the background code already completed, but I am debating whether or not to go as far as to have a "blank" user that the forum uses for all posts in the specified forum. This would make it totally anonymous.
The other option is to simply hide all of the user's personal information when the posts are displayed. The down side to this method is that if someone is posting a complaint about the admins/mods, their MEMBER_ID is still stored in the database. So without a whole lot of work, a vengeful admin could find out who posted.
I am leaning towards the blank user, but thought I'd see what people here had to say on the subject before doing that part of it.<
Bill Parrott
Senior Web Programmer, University of Kansas
Co-Owner and Code Monkey, Eternal Second Designs (www.eternalsecond.com)
Personal Website (www.chimericdream.com)
 Sort direction, for dates DESC means newest first  
 Page size 
Posted
Average Member
phy1729
Posts: 589
589
Well an admin is supposed to be trusted not to do that so I'd go for an if mlev=4 then show username conditional. Also make sure you clear the last post on default.asp and forum.asp<
Posted
Senior Member
muzishun
Posts: 1079
1079
I agree that an admin is supposed to be trusted. However, sometimes complaints may be *about* the admin of a forum, which would cause some users to refrain from posting if they thought/knew that the admin could figure out their identity.
As for the last post on default.asp and forum.asp, I have already taken care of both of those places so far. I will also need to change post.asp to keep a user's name out of a quoted reply.<
Bill Parrott
Senior Web Programmer, University of Kansas
Co-Owner and Code Monkey, Eternal Second Designs (www.eternalsecond.com)
Personal Website (www.chimericdream.com)
Posted
Support Moderator
Podge
Posts: 3776
3776
I think you should record the member, for the same reason you record member votes in the Poll mod, it prevents abuse. <
Posted
Senior Member
muzishun
Posts: 1079
1079
That's a good point. So... so far we have two votes for recording member ID and my inclination otherwise. It looks like the general thought may be against me here.
Side note: Podge, I think we're following each other around the threads right now. Don't worry, though. I'm about to be off work, so I won't post for at least a few minutes wink.<
Bill Parrott
Senior Web Programmer, University of Kansas
Co-Owner and Code Monkey, Eternal Second Designs (www.eternalsecond.com)
Personal Website (www.chimericdream.com)
Posted
Average Member
phy1729
Posts: 589
589
Well you always could put a const in config.asp such as OpinionModRecordID that will let the user choose.<
Posted
Support Moderator
Podge
Posts: 3776
3776
bigsmile Well, I'm off to sleep now <
Posted
Senior Member
bobby131313
Posts: 1163
1163
which would cause some users to refrain from posting if they thought/knew that the admin could figure out their identity.

I think they would think that regardless of what you do.<
Posted
Senior Member
MaD2ko0l
Posts: 1053
1053
if u r complainign about an admin andyway...it dont really matter due to the fact that the admin says what happends...so really if u dont liek what an admin is doing u dont have to go to that admins forum at all and its 1 less person to contribute to there forum...u cannot please everyone :-)<
© 1999-2010 MaD2ko0l
Posted
Senior Member
muzishun
Posts: 1079
1079
All good points. I think, for simplicity's sake, I will stick with leaving the user's info in the database. Thanks for the opinions. I'm hoping to have the MOD ready for testing sometime tomorrow.<
Bill Parrott
Senior Web Programmer, University of Kansas
Co-Owner and Code Monkey, Eternal Second Designs (www.eternalsecond.com)
Personal Website (www.chimericdream.com)
Posted
Advanced Member
JJenson
Posts: 2121
2121
muzishun did you ever get this working? I have one forum I want this for on a site for an HOA that can give opinions without people knowing who they are.
<
You Must enter a message