Mark,
When I posted my previous reply I had to post and run (was time for dinner).
After a nice dinner I looked a bit longer at the code in post.asp
If you make the blue code changes in post.asp it will only show the newest X replies (sorted descending, meaning newest first). The number of replies shown is the same as the number of posts normally shown on one page (set in the Admin Options).
The code shown below starts at about line 1012 in post.asp:
	'## Forum_SQL - Get all replies to Topic from the DB
	strSql ="SELECT " & strMemberTablePrefix & "MEMBERS.M_NAME, " & strTablePrefix & "REPLY.R_MESSAGE "
	strSql = strSql & " FROM " & strMemberTablePrefix & "MEMBERS, " & strTablePrefix & "REPLY "
	strSql = strSql & " WHERE " & strMemberTablePrefix & "MEMBERS.MEMBER_ID = " & strTablePrefix & "REPLY.R_AUTHOR "
	strSql = strSql & " AND   TOPIC_ID = " & Request.QueryString("TOPIC_ID") & " "
	strSql = strSql & " ORDER BY " & strTablePrefix & "REPLY.R_DATE DESC"
	set rs = Server.CreateObject("ADODB.Recordset")
	rs.open  strSql, my_Conn, 3	
	
	strI = 0 
	intRecordcount = 1
	if rs.EOF or rs.BOF then
		Response.Write ""
	else
		Response.Write("<tr>")
		Response.Write("<td bgcolor=""" & strHeadCellColor & """ colspan=""2"" align=""center""><b><font face=""" & strDefaultFontFace & """ size=""" & strDefaultFontSize & """ color=""" & strHeadFontColor & """>")
		Response.Write("L A T E S T  R E P L I E S  (Newest First)</font></b></td></tr>")
		rs.movefirst
		do until (rs.EOF or (intRecordCount > strPageSize))
  			if strI = 0 then
	 			CColor = strAltForumCellColor
			else
				CColor = strForumCellColor
			end if
			Response.Write "      <TR>" & vbCrLf   & _
						   "        <TD bgcolor='" & CColor & "' valign='top'"
			if lcase(strTopicNoWrapLeft) = "1" then
				Response.Write " nowrap"
			end if 
			Response.Write "><b><font color='" & strForumFontColor & "' face='" & strDefaultFontFace & "' size='2'>" &  ChkString(rs("M_NAME"),"display") & "</font></b></td>" & vbCrLf & _
						   "        <TD bgcolor='" & CColor & "' valign='top'"
			if lcase(strTopicNoWrapRight) = "1" then
				Response.Write " nowrap"
			end if
			Response.Write "><font color='" & strForumFontColor & "' face='" & strDefaultFontFace & "' size='2'>" & formatStr(rs("R_MESSAGE")) & "</font></td>" & vbCrLf & _
						   "      </tr>" & vbCrLf
			rs.MoveNext
			intRecordcount = intRecordcount + 1
			strI = strI + 1
			if strI = 2 then 
				strI = 0
			end if
		loop
	end if
Seeing the large number of replies on some of the Mod-topics this might be something to add to the source code..... (Mike ?)
Pierre<